A Study of Deng Shi’s “New Historiography” Thought on Fine Arts
Keywords:
Deng Shi; New Historiography; The Thought on Fine Arts; The National Essence School; Nationalist; Modern Chinese Art HistoryAbstract
Modern Chinese “new historiography” has both maintained close ties with the fine arts and exerted a significant influence on their development. Currently, there is a lack of specific case studies on the relationship between modern Chinese history and art. Additionally, research and reflection on the ideas and problems arising from the interaction between modern history and art still have room for improvement. This paper focuses on modern historian Deng Shi. Through an analysis of his activities in the field of fine arts, the paper expounds on his views on history and fine arts and discusses how his ideas on fine arts were formed in the context of the new historiography movement. It reflects on the relationship between modern history and fine arts and analyzes the logic behind the formation of modern Chinese art history. In this regard, this paper adopts an interdisciplinary research methodology to examine the evolution of modern art history and artistic production through the lens of modern historiography, while also incorporating the perspectives and conceptual contributions of art scholars. Concurrently, employing a dual approach of historical text interpretation and close reading methods, this paper offers an interpretation of the historical texts of modern scholars, thereby restoring the historical context and examining Deng Shi's academic views on art and their underlying internal causes. This paper argues that: the combination of modern history and fine arts has not only deepened the connotation of fine arts and promoted the updating of the research methodology of fine arts history, but has also led to a certain extent to the deviation of the value orientation of fine arts research, but on the whole, the combination of history and fine arts has far-reaching significance for the development of modern Chinese fine arts history.
Downloads
References
Bei, W. Q. (2007). Tang Cheng furen muzhiming taben de faxian ji jiedu [The discovery and interpretation of rubbings of inscription on the memorial tablet within Madam Cheng's tomb in Tang Dynasty]. Journal of Zhejiang Ocean University: Humanities Science Edition, (1), 41–44. https://shorturl.at/suKI5
Chen, C. Y. (2011). Zhongguo xiandai meishuxue shi [History of modern Chinese art studies]. Heilongjiang Fine Arts Publishing House.
Chen, S., Li, Y., Qi, K., & Xing, X. (2022). A general history of Chinese art: Sui and Tang dynasties. De Gruyter.
Chia-fu, S. (2019). Guoshi or national history in modern Chinese historiography: From Zhang Taiyan to Qian Mu. Tsing Hua Journal of Chinese Studies, (04). https://doi.org/10.6503/THJCS.201912
Chia-Ying Yeh, F. (2018). Seven lectures on Wang Guowei’s Renjian Cihua. Routledge.
Claypool, L. (2011). Ways of seeing the nation: Chinese painting in the National Essence Journal (1905–1911) and exhibition culture. positions: east asia cultures critique, 19(1), 55–82. https://doi.org/10.1215/10679847-2010-024
Deng, S. (1902). Shixue tonglun [General theory of historiography]. Zhengyi tongbao [Bulletin of politics and the arts], (12).
Deng, S. (1904). Minshi zongxu [General history of the people]. Zhengyi tongbao [Bulletin of politics and the arts], (17).
Deng, S. (1905). Guoxue weilun [A brief discussion on national learning]. Guocui xuebao [Journal of National Essence], (2).
Deng, S. (1905). Guxue fuxing lun [The thought of “revival of ancient studies”]. Guocui xuebao [Journal of National Essence], (9).
Deng, S. (1906). Wenxinguo moji [Wen Xingguo's calligraphy]. Guocui xuebao [Journal of National Essence], (17).
Deng, S. (1906). Yuewumu shi moji [Yue Wumu's poetic calligraphy]. Guocui xuebao [Journal of National Essence], (16).
Deng, S. (1907). Cai Junmo caoshu zhenji [Cai Junmo's authentic cursive script]. Guocui xuebao [Journal of National Essence], (9).
Deng, S. (1907). Guoxue baocun hui dishijiuhao baogao [Report No. 19 of the Society for Preserving National Learning]. Guocui xuebao [Journal of National Essence], (29).
Deng, S. (1907). Huangzhonduan gong ti xuejiang canhua [Huang Zhongduan Gong's inscription on “Snow-covered River”]. Guocui xuebao [Journal of National Essence], (35).
Deng, S. (1908). Ming liutingmei xishan shenxiu tu [Deep and beautiful landscape by Liu Tingmei in Ming Dynasty]. Guocui xuebao [Journal of National Essence], (38).
Deng, S. (1908). Ming tangziwei guanquan tu [Tang Yin's “Viewing the Spring” painting]. Guocui xuebao [Journal of National Essence], (38).
Deng, S. (1908). Song huizong baiying tu [Emperor Huizong’s “White Eagle” painting]. Guocui xuebao [Journal of National Essence], (38).
Deng, S. (1908). Tangkaicheng ernianbei fajian yu hainan [Discovery of a stele from the second year of Kai Cheng in Hainan]. Guocui xuebao [Journal of National Essence], (43).
Deng, S. (1908). Ti bisonglou cangshu yuanliukao shi [Origin and history of books in the Bi Song Lou collection]. Guocui xuebao [Journal of National Essence], (43).
Deng, S. (1909). Jinshi baocun [Preservation of metal and stone artifacts]. Guocui xuebao [Journal of National Essence], (52).
Deng, S. (1910). Dunhuang shishi yishu [Remains of books from the Dunhuang Grottoes]. Guocui xuebao [Journal of National Essence], (64).
Deng, S. (1910). Ming zhusansong shanshui juanben [Landscape on silk by Zhu Sansong]. Guocui xuebao [Journal of National Essence], (2).
Deng, S. (1911). Ming yimin Yetianmiu yizha [Letters of Ye Tianliao, survivor of the Ming Dynasty]. Guocui xuebao [Journal of National Essence], (76).
Deng, S. (1927). Fengyulou yiquan tulu [Illustrated catalog of rare coins in Fengyu Tower]. Guquan zazhi [Ancient Coin Magazine], (1).
Deng, S. (2013). Tanyi lu [Discussions on arts]. In H. B. H. & S. Deng (Eds.), Meishu congshu [Fine arts series] (Vol. 30, 3rd series, Vol. 10, pp. 251–309). Zhejiang People's Fine Arts Publishing House. (Original work published 1928)
Deng, S. (2014). Fengyulou duhua xiaoji [Reading paintings in the Wind and Rain Pavilion]. In S. Deng & B. H. Huang (Eds.), Shenzhou Guoguang Ji [Collection of National Glory of China] (Vol. 9, p. 6). Zhejiang People's Fine Arts Publishing House. (Original work published 1909)
Deng, S. (2014). Jilu yutan [Compilation of miscellaneous discussions]. In S. Deng & B. H. Huang (Eds.), Shenzhou Guoguang Ji [Collection of National Glory of China] (Vol. 20, p. 2). Zhejiang People's Fine Arts Publishing House. (Original work published 1911)
Deng, S. (2014). Xu [Preface]. In S. Deng & B. H. Huang (Eds.), Shenzhou Guoguang Ji [Collection of National Glory of China] (Vol. 1, p. 1). Zhejiang People's Fine Arts Publishing House. (Original work published 1908)
Ding, Y. (2019). Chamber with winds and rains: On the collecting practice of Deng Shi and his contemporaries (Doctoral dissertation, Cornell University). https://doi.org/10.7298/6cq5-2g13
Fuchs, E. (2011). Contemporary alternatives to German historicism in the nineteenth century. In S. Macintyre, J. Maiguashca, & A. Pók (Eds.), The Oxford history of historical writing (pp. 59–76). Oxford University Press.
Han, Q. L. (2011). Zisha guji jinyi [Modern translation of ancient purple clay texts]. Beijing Publishing House.
Heizer, R. F. (1962). The background of Thomsen’s three-age system. Technology and Culture, 3(3), 259–266. https://doi.org/10.2307/3100819
Hong, Z. X. (2013). Cong minzu zhuyi dao xiandai zhuyi: Deng Shi, Huang Binhong xueshu sixiang guanxi kaolue [From nationalism to modernism: A study on academic thought of Deng Shi & Huang Binhong]. Art Journal, (4), 27. https://shorturl.at/0eArE
Hui, G. (2014). Canonization in early twentieth-century Chinese art history. Journal of Art Historiography, (10), 7. https://arthistoriography.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/06/hui1.pdf
Jiao, R. M. (1999). Zhongguo jindai wenhuashi [Modern Chinese cultural history]. Liaoning University Press.
Kahn, H., & Feuerwerker, A. (1965). The ideology of scholarship: China’s new historiography. The China Quarterly, (22), 1–13.
Kockum, K. (1988). Liang Qichao: The Japanese years. Cina, 21, 195–203.
Kong, L. W. (2008). “Xin shixue” yu jindai zhongguo meishushi yanjiu de xingqi [The “New Historiography” and the rise of art history research in modern China]. New Arts, (4), 49. https://shorturl.at/AHivZ
Liang, Q. C. (1902). Dongji yuedan [Notes on Japanese books]. Xinmin congbao [New Citizen's Journal], (11), 112.
Liu, J. (2022). The general theory of Dunhuang studies. Springer.
Liu, S. P. (1907). Zhongguo meishuxue bianqian lun [On the development of Chinese art studies]. Guocui xuebao [Journal of National Essence], (30–31).
Luo, Z. (2015). Inheritance within rupture: Culture and scholarship in early twentieth century China. Brill Academic Publishers.
Luo, Z. Y., & Cai, S. (1909). Han banliangjia qianfan [Mold for Banliang coins]. Guocui xuebao [Journal of National Essence], (50).
Ma, X. L. (1903). Shijie datong shuo [Universal unity in historiography]. Zhengyi tongbao [Bulletin of politics and the arts], (16).
Marija, S. (2014). Liang Qichao and his impact on new Chinese historiography. In J. S. Rošker & N. V. Suhadolnik (Eds.), Modernisation of Chinese culture: Continuity and change (p. 86). Cambridge Scholars Publishing.
Qiao, Z. Q. (2016). Ershi shiji zhongguo meishu shixueshi yanjiu [History of Chinese art historiography in the 20th century]. Guangdong People's Publishing House.
Roberts, C. (2005). The dark side of the mountain: Huang Binhong (1865–1955) and artistic continuity in twentieth century China (Doctoral dissertation, Australian National University). https://doi.org/10.25911/5d739732ea4b3
Robinson, J. H. (1911). The new history. Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society, (50), 179–190.
Schneider, J. C. (2023). Chinese nationalism in late Qing times. In Z. Lu (Ed.), The Routledge handbook of nationalism in East and Southeast Asia (pp. 109–111). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003111450
Schneider, L. (1976). National essence and the new intelligentsia. In C. Furth (Ed.), The limits of change: Essays on conservative alternatives in Republican China (pp. 57–89). Harvard University Press. https://doi.org/10.4159/harvard.9780674332966.c5
Shao, H. (2007). Art history: A Western discipline’s centennial experience in China. Frontiers of Literary Studies in China, 1(4), 523–542. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11702-007-0024-4
Wang, C. H. (2011). In the name of the nation: Song painting and artistic discourse in early twentieth-century China. In A companion to Asian art and architecture (pp. 537–560).
Wang, G. W. (2015). Lun jiaoyu zhi zongzhi [On the purpose of education]. In Renjian cihua [Comments on ci poetry] (p. 137). Anhui Literature and Art Publishing House. (Original work published 1906)
Wang, G. W. (2015). Wenxue xiaoyan [Literary essays]. In Renjian cihua [Comments on ci poetry] (pp. 201–202). Anhui Literature and Art Publishing House. (Original work published 1907)
Wang, Q. E. (2001). China’s search for national history. In Q. E. Wang & G. G. Iggers (Eds.), Turning points in historiography (p. 197). Boydell & Brewer.
Wang, Q. E. (2011). Narrating the nation: Meiji historiography, new history textbooks, and disciplinarization in China. In B. Moloughney & P. Zarrow (Eds.), Transforming history: The making of a modern academic discipline in twentieth-century China (pp. 117–123). Chinese University Press.
Wang, Z. H. (2011). Luo Zhenyu’s collection and publications: Formation of Qiwuxue. Taida Journal of Art History, (9), 277–320. https://toaj.stpi.niar.org.tw/index/journal/volume/article/4b1141f9864ed86b01864f09eb29007e
Xu, A. (2021). From culturalist nationalism to conservatism: Origins and diversification of conservative ideas in Republican China. De Gruyter. https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110740189
Yiyang, S. (2016). Wither art history? The Art Bulletin, 98(2), 147–150. https://doi.org/10.1080/00043079.2016.1108146
Zarrow, P. (2003). Old myth into new history: The building blocks of Liang Qichao's “New History”. Historiography East and West, 1(2), 209–213.
Zhang, H. Y. (2008). Zhongguo kaoguxue bajiang [Eighteen lectures on Chinese archaeology]. Shanxi People's Publishing House.
Zhang, Y. Y. (1993). Lidai minghua ji [Records of famous paintings through the dynasties]. In F. S. Lu (Ed.), Zhongguo shuhua quanshu [The complete works of Chinese calligraphy and painting] (p. 119). Shanghai Calligraphy and Painting Publishing House. (Original work published 815–879)
Zhao, G. (2006). Reinventing China: Imperial Qing ideology and the rise of modern Chinese national identity. Modern China, 32(1), 3–30. https://doi.org/10.1177/0097700405282349
Zheng, S. Q. (2014). Wanqing guocuipai wenhua sixiang yanjiu [Cultural thought of the National Essence School in the late Qing Dynasty]. Beijing Normal University Press.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Herança
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
8.png)
